Problem/Issue Statement
Pandora.com faces two options following the 2007 royalties increase implemented by the Copyright Royalty Board (or CRB). Tim Westergren, Founder and Chief Strategy Officer, could either seek to move in a conservative direction avoiding risk due to fast growth or move forward with additional capital and potentially capitalize on the growing, online music scene as the first mover. Currently, investors are concerned about the companies' future profitability following steep royalty increases.
Situation Assessment
Tim Westergren began Pandora using the backend system of the Music Genome Project. This leveraged Pandora's ability to analyze music and allow customers to use the engine in order to find music similar to their initial choice. Pandora Radio began in 2004 with initial funding from Walden Venture Capital. This allowed Westergren and his team to move away from providing a supportive platform to third-party vendors, such as AOL and Best Buy, and becoming an self-sustainable company.
The industry had shifted. As cassettes moved out of the way for CDs, now CDs were shifting to streaming, satellite and digital music purchases. This proved a paradigm shift for the industry as users could purchase only those songs they wished to buy, share and save in many formats. (Cell phone, MP3 player, computer, etc.) This shift was monumental for the industry as the focus became more consumer-centric; customized based on each individual preference. The margins were no longer there for a single song purchased at .99 cents on iTunes or sponsored, 'free' music via online radio. The CRB was in a difficult position to re-examine the royalty structure.
The CRB increased royalties for streaming, online music stations. This pushed CEO Joe Kennedy and founder Tim Westergren to issue an appeal to their 5 million subscribers (in 2007) asking for support to save online radio and write to their congress persons.
Recommendation
Tim, I recommend fighting the CRB on the royalties increase and seek negotiations with the music label's governing body. I would also recommend increasing capital to push forward with greater expansion and increased database.
The CRB has limited data on the impact of online radio stations at this time, and any increase will be based on unsubstantial data that can change over time. Online streaming radio also generates greater volume in listeners than traditional mediums. For these reasons, I believe the CRB, and Congress, will be in a position to negotiate down the rate.
I recommend pushing forward with greater funding due to numerous new platforms to stream online music. Missing these opportunities as a first mover will negate the current strength Pandora has in the marketplace.
Presentation
In presenting this case study, I would seek to compare the number and growth of listeners in traditional mediums (i.e. CD sales, radio advertising dollars, and satellite provider subscriptions) against those that subscribe to online radio.
My goal would be to show the break-even point where, due to the sheer volume of online radio subscribers, Pandora can achieve 'economies of scale' not attainable in other forms of music dissemination. This will show the value of online radio. To show the break-even point should not be rushed, my goal would be to show the consistently changing landscape of the music industry and a companies' need to remain flexible to shift with the changes by providing a low-risk investment for capital investors. Without these investments, an online radio company will not be able to grow enough to be sustainable while providing greater returns in royalties than traditional media.
No comments:
Post a Comment