Good afternoon,
We are taking a look at the practicality of implementing the Ubuntu operating system in lieu of our current Mac OS X 10.7.5 operating system and the potential option of changing to a Windows platform. Ubuntu provides a number of strengths and I've focused my comparison one three major areas: cost, compatibility, and functionality.
Cost
The Ubuntu desktop is free, and back-up to its U-Cloud is available with 5 GB free storage. Compared to Mac OS X, each license costs $30. Windows OS 8, for a clean install, will cost us approximately $120 per license. As a business solution, Ubuntu provides server, cloud back-up, and support via Canonical, though the cost is unknown. Some companies that use Ubuntu as a business solution include Qualcomm and WetaDigital.
Software on Ubuntu's app store is also free. These include replacements for Microsoft Office, LibreOffice, media players, planners & schedulers and 1,000+ other apps. On cost alone, Ubuntu is the clear winner at no cost and enterprise-level offerings at some cost.
Compatibility & Functionality
Mac OS X provides the ability to synchronize with all other Apple OS devices seamlessly out of the box. Upon a trial run of Ubuntu, I found I could not sync the apps on my iPhone to Ubuntu for back-up. I was able to access my photo and media libraries for back-up, however. The pre-installed office suite, LibreOffice, exports to formats such as , xls, csv, HTML and jpg. Though the office suite is capable of completing similar functionality of Microsoft Office for Mac or Windows, the interface is difficult to navigate if one is used to MS Office.
Other strengths include its iCloud-comparable cloud service, U Cloud, and equally comparable out-of-the-box software. Word processing, spreadsheet and presentation creation are all comparable in functionality and feel, though the layouts are different. This will cause a steeper, initial learning curve. Other functionality, such as media playback and sync are available and functional.
Weaknesses of Ubuntu
When running games on both Mac and Ubuntu operating systems, I found the Ubuntu framerate to be much slower than its Mac counterpart. The graphics engine of the OS does not seem to be on par.
Many of the functions available on Mac out-of-the-box require downloads (though freeware) on the Ubuntu platform.
Strengths of Ubuntu
Cost is the primary attribute. However, for a stand-alone desktop OS with minimal graphics requirements or complex processing, Ubuntu provides a similar feel to smart phones with its "there's an app for that" philosophy. This provides the same level of average desktop use most users seek in an OS. The internet search functionality is very nice, though no different than opening a browser window or apps available for the Mac OS LaunchPad. The ability to save webpage data for quick recollection is nice, but no different then advanced cookie functions on a Mac.
I recommend Ubuntu to those who seek a free alternative to the common functionality found on Windows and Macs. For more advanced users, gamers, or enterprise solutions, I recommend remaining with the Mac or Windows world.
No comments:
Post a Comment