Problem/issue statement
Proctor & Gamble's (P&G) prescription drug division was the fastest growing at more than 33% annual growth rate in 1997, yet ROI remained highly dependent upon time a product is in the market. A single day product launch was delayed, revenue is estimated to decrease by $1 million. With such an effect on ROI, P&G's Ray D'Alonzo began seeking ways to decrease the excessive amount of time required during trials in phase I-III before a drug was submitted for FDA approval and released to the public.
Situation Analysis
Time is critical between the beginning of data generation during trial studies in phase I-III and the period of data lock, or the period where data is submitted for review with the Data Safety Monitoring Board (DSMB). Currently, P&G uses a paper-based system to track trial data. There are multiple redundant steps, data transfer is limited to mail and person-to-person providing numerous opportunities to save time during trials.
Plausible Alternative Options and Evaluation
Three options are considered in taking advantage of this highly lucrative opportunity.
1. Improve the paper system by implementing overnight shipping. The overhead costs, processing times, security risks, and minimal gain compared to alternatives does not make this an appealing option. Should all things held constant with the exception of time saved, this would be a viable alternative.
2. Implement a digial imaging system for data transfer. Faxing documents would be used. This option, though faster, more secure and lower processing time than improving the paper system provides marginal improvements in time to data lock. This option does not take advantage of all opportunities available created by the paper system. It also does not replace, but supplement the paper system.
3. Electronic Data Capture, or EDC, allows data to be input on-site into a web-based data collection system. this option eliminates the paper system taking full advantage of all opportunities the prior system had created. Though the greatest amount of time can be saved by implementing an EDC system, new obstacles are created. These include the necessity of peripheral services, technological learning curves, increased security concerns, and infrastructure obstacles.
Recommendation
Though new obstacles are created, implementing an EDC system provides the greatest promise of increased revenue by decreasing the amount of time to data lock by approximately 5 weeks. Expected returns could be as high as $49 million increase in ROI minus EDC overhead and implementation; a significant accomplishment if implemented successfully.
Presentation
When presenting this recommendation, graphically representing the opportunities that save time will help clarify redundant systems and visually identify a more streamlined approach to data collection and transfer. The comparison of potential outcomes under each alternative would help quantify the value capitalized upon by choosing one alternative over another. The two primary benchmarks are time saved, and profitability of a drug under each system.
No comments:
Post a Comment